Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza Buckhead

Neecy Nei a month ago

The service is amazing. I went on a busy Friday night and the restaurant was a well oiled machine. The servers were kind and accommodating. Now, the food was immaculate! We had one of the star pizzas with ricotta stuffed crust and it was amazing. We also had the Caesar salad which was also delicious. One salad and one pizza fed 3 people with leftovers. We got the dessert pizza to go! We will be back!

Robert Sawyer 3 months ago

Had been on the list for a while and finally made it. Reminds me of New Haven style, Frank Pepe type pizza from Connecticut. It’s a welcomed variety I haven’t had around Atlanta. Service is really good not just in greeting but in clearing tables, napkin and silverware changing, replenishment of water and changing out of plates. It’s well run with an all team approach of engaging tables with top tier service without being intrusive. Favorite was the Coffee Paola which had a slight aroma of coffee but had a slight sweet honey finish. Meat Lovers 2.0 is a close second. All our choices were tasty and promptly served fresh and hot. All of the ingredients complimented the taste without overpowering. A thin crust but not cracker dry which often times if not cooked properly in this style can happen. Here, they do it right. Plentiful salad to share which pairs well with a splash of balsamic, olive oil and a dash of salt. Recommended with enthusiasm.

Yamila Nouaouri Smith 3 months ago

Had an amazing experience at Mister O easily some of the best pizza I’ve had in the area. The crust was perfectly crisp on the outside but still soft and airy inside, and everything tasted super fresh without being heavy or greasy. What really made it stand out was the service. Riley was our waitress and she was incredible: attentive without being overbearing, super friendly, and made great recommendations that we actually ended up loving. She really elevated the whole experience. Vibe was great too, chill but still lively, perfect spot whether you’re grabbing a casual dinner or hanging out with friends. Definitely a place I’d come back to again.

akshay reddy 4 months ago

Visited Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza in Atlanta and absolutely loved the experience. First of all, the history of the owner really amazed me, and I loved the story behind the restaurant’s name. It made the place feel even more special. The restaurant was packed when we got there — every table was full — which is always a good sign. Thankfully, we got seated and started with a couple of their burratas. They were delicious and came with these super thin sourdough naan-like breads that tasted amazing. For pizzas, we ordered the Spicy Salami Star Pizza and the Star Michele Pizza. The Spicy Salami was definitely my favorite — flavorful, perfectly baked, and the spicy salami was excellent. The Star Michele was really good too. I thought the ricotta cheese might feel too heavy by the end of the meal, but surprisingly the pizza was balanced and enjoyable throughout. Overall, great atmosphere, quality ingredients, and unique pizzas that stand out from the usual spots. Definitely worth visiting if you’re in Atlanta and love pizza.

Anand 7 months ago

I got the Star Luca and loved it so much that I finished the entire thing myself. No wonder the chef came to the US on an O1 visa lol. The unique presentation, thin crust and flavorful toppings make the meal an experience. The spicy chili olive oil just brings everything together so well. You can even buy this olive oil separately. Highly recommend. I love how this is walking distance from hotels and malls nearby. Service was good, they came around to check on my frequently and were polite.